What it says
Shiotsuka said that in some respects she has something to say through a song, and in others nothing at all. She is glad when people tell her they are truly grateful a song exists, yet she also feels she never set out to write that kind of song, and she wrote this one when that gap had worn her down a little. She also said that with “more than words” she wanted to declare “this is what I want to do”, even if people stopped listening because it wasn't like before, and that she put that feeling into “honestly”.
Making it
Shiotsuka sent a programmed demo of the song, track 8 on the album, to a friend. The friend said that a person like the one in the lyrics might really be in pieces, but that it was nice how the words sat on such a light tune. That was a part Shiotsuka liked too, so she was happy to hear it. Fukuda described it as a song that drives stoically on a 16-beat all the way through, and said it reflects Shiotsuka's state of mind when she wrote it.
What it means to them
Asked for their favourite songs on “12 hugs (like butterflies)”, Shiotsuka named “honestly” alongside “人魚” and “つづく”, and Fukuda named it alongside “Flower”. In 2025, Kasai agreed that its theme was close to that of “doll”. Shiotsuka summed up the shared idea as “you don't really know me, do you?” and said that in “doll” she wanted to express it in a more girly way.