Overall
Throughout, two things stayed constant: the view that pop is part of who they are, and the stance of making what they think is good. What moved was a swing from consciously making reach the axis in the “our hope” period to putting their own taste first again on the next album.
2016
In 2016, Shiotsuka said their upcoming self-release was made with the idea of “doing everything we want”, so its songs might not seem likely to sell, and Fukuda added that it lacked mass appeal.
2019
In 2019, she explained that the EP “きらめき” did not mean the band had changed; they had simply let out, without holding back, a pop side that had always been in them.
2020
In February 2020 she described “きらめき” as a challenge to show sides they had not expressed before, such as pop-ness, and the follow-up “ざわめき” as boldly showing “the honest us”. She added that she may have been a little conscious of going back to the start, and that having released “きらめき” made the band's current growth stand out more. That December she said the pop of “きらめき” and the robustness of “ざわめき” are both “us”, and that being able to do both is a strength.
2022
In April 2022, Shiotsuka said she had wondered whether their music should be easier to understand, but concluded that they should simply make music they themselves think is good. Around the same time, Shiotsuka and Fukuda described the theme of “our hope” as reaching more people. Shiotsuka mentioned trying a clearer sound image, and added that using reach as the deciding axis when unsure applied less to the songs themselves than to things like which media to appear in. Kasai said they pushed some arrangements fully toward pop and, conversely, tried ambient, while Shiotsuka called it an easy album to listen to as a whole.
2023
In 2023, Shiotsuka said their past work had been inward-looking but this time they had decided early on to reach more people, and Kasai described the album as blending pop elements with their own style. The members were delighted that winning the CD Shop Awards meant their music had been heard by many people, and Shiotsuka recalled pursuing a clearer, easier-to-grasp sound image and a more pop approach right to the end of the album. With “12 hugs (like butterflies)” at the end of that year, the answer turned. Shiotsuka said the arrow now pointed at herself rather than outward, and she stated the change herself: the previous album was deliberately pop, while this time they did as they liked, and she did not want to yield anything until it reached a quality she thought was good. Kasai likewise said that this time, while still minding how easy it was to listen to, they picked what they liked whenever they were unsure and ultimately went with their own character. Fukuda saw the new record as a return to their roots, coming after the second album's aim of combining J-pop (pop-ness) with alternative rock, and described it as balancing an edgy sound with mass appeal.
2024
In 2024, Shiotsuka said this album had answered the question of what Hitsujibungaku is. At the end of the year she still said they had truly done what they wanted.
2025
In July 2025, Shiotsuka admitted that parts of her earlier work were a little different from what she wanted to do. She said her tie-in songs managed to serve both the anime's world and what she wanted, and that she had never thought she had to write the next hit. In October she said she had gathered the more accessible songs, mostly tie-ins, onto this album so she could move on to a record of noisy songs like “doll”. In December she said she now felt free to drop ideas like “our band has to be like this”, and that for once she had set aside the rule of building songs only from guitar, bass, drums, vocals and backing vocals, a shift that came partly through the tie-ins.
Every passage on this question, by date26
20161
BiRTH.ep was a self-introduction marking the band's rebirth; the September release is about doing everything they want while they can still self-release.
Shiotsuka: やりたいことは全部やろう、という思いで作っています。Hascuration ↗20191
She says “きらめき” isn't the band changing but letting out a pop side they always had; “ロマンス” and “ミルク” are older songs.
Shiotsuka: バンドが変わったというよりは、私たちの中にもともとあったポップな部分を、我慢せずに出してみたという感じですね。OTOTOY ↗20203
She planned a counterpart when releasing “きらめき”; that EP tried pop and girlishness, while this one boldly shows “the candid us”. Fukuda notes their first four-on-the-floor beat.
Shiotsuka & Fukuda: 『きらめき』を出した時点で、後で対になるようなものを出そうと思っていて。FUDGE ↗Shiotsuka says the five songs share no set theme but hint at a return to roots; having released “きらめき” makes the band's growth stand out more.
Shiotsuka: 「きらめき」を出したおかげで、今の羊文学の発展した感じがより際立つんじゃないかなと思っています。WHAT's IN? tokyo ↗Since her clothes and music shift with her mood, Shiotsuka prefers a varied album; both the pop of “きらめき” and the grit of “ざわめき” are who they are.
Shiotsuka: 『きらめき』のポップさも、『ざわめき』の骨太感も、どちらの側面も私たちだと思っているので。OTOTOY ↗20224
She is honoured that high schoolers voted them the band they most admire; she wondered about making their music more accessible, but it only deepened her belief in making music they themselves think is good.
Shiotsuka: 自分たちなりにいいと思った音楽をやればいいし、周りからの反応によって、その思いが深まった感じです装苑ONLINE ↗Shiotsuka says reaching more people is their theme for this year and next, and they use it as the yardstick whenever they're unsure.
Shiotsuka: 何か迷ったときに「多くの人に届くかどうか」を軸にやってみようってTHE FIRST TIMES ↗Shiotsuka names two themes: reaching more listeners, and, as it turned out, city life — her move to Shinjuku seeps through the songs.
Shiotsuka: 自分たちの世界が広くなってきたので、より多くの人に聴いてもらうことを軸にやっていこうGINZA ↗“our hope” aimed for an urban feel and a wider audience while trying new sounds; Shiotsuka sees it as gaining depth through the band's growth.
Shiotsuka: 年齢的な成長やバンドとしての成長があって、奥行きが加わったイメージでこのアルバムを捉えていますFenderNews ↗202310
Shiotsuka says she unconsciously wrote about her changing surroundings on “our hope”, only later noticing a “Tokyo” theme; it's more open than before.
Shiotsuka: 過去的作品是比較內向的,但這次在初期我們就決定要讓更多人聽見Unipa ↗Kasai says “our hope” aimed to reach many people, blending pop elements with their own style, and marked their first anime collaboration.
Kasai: 這張專輯以「希望讓很多人聽見」作為主題LikeJapan ↗The members say “our hope” winning the CD Shop Awards shows their music reached many listeners, and they are thrilled.
代表他們的音樂被相當多人聽見,為此感到非常開心KKBOX ↗Shiotsuka says “our hope” was built around reaching more listeners, aiming for a clearer, more accessible musical picture than ever before.
Shiotsuka: 這次是以為了讓更多人聽到為主題,並追求至今為止還要更加清晰、更淺顯易懂的音樂圖像。In Western Music ↗Shiotsuka says “12 hugs (like butterflies)” naturally points inward rather than outward, with an unforced atmosphere throughout that earlier albums lacked.
Shiotsuka: 外に向けてではなくて、自分に矢印が向いているというか。J-WAVE NEWS ↗Kasai calls it a return to the music they love after going all-out pop on “our hope”; Fukuda describes it as a back-to-roots record.
Kasai & Fukuda: もともと好きだった音楽に立ち返って、それを今の自分たちで表現した作品なのかなとAERA dot. ↗Shiotsuka says the last album was deliberately poppy, but this time she compromised on nothing; Fukuda felt a return to their roots.
Shiotsuka: 自分が良いと思うクオリティになるまで、何も譲りたくなかった。Billboard JAPAN ↗Kasai says that whenever they were torn, they chose what they themselves liked; Fukuda explains the theme is “hugging yourself” and the album returns to the band's roots.
Fukuda: バタフライハグ、つまり“自分自身をハグする”がテーマでFenderNews ↗Kasai says “acceptance” is the album's big theme and they prioritised being themselves over accessibility; Fukuda calls it a return to their roots.
Kasai: 「受け入れる」みたいなことはすごく大きなテーマになっていて。Kompass / CINRA ↗Fukuda says the album returns to their roots, aiming for a newness only possible now. Kasai feels this time they knew when to ease off.
Fukuda & Kasai: いろいろな経験をした今ならではの新しさが出せるのでは、と。Oggi.jp ↗20244
Shiotsuka says their last album deliberately aimed at pop, but this time they did what they wanted without compromise; Fukuda felt he returned to his edgy roots.
Shiotsuka: I didn’t want to yield anything until I reached a quality that I thought was good.Billboard ↗Kasai notes listeners' favourite tracks varied widely; Fukuda calls the third album a return to roots, played on initial impulse, with ghost notes and natural habits in the drums.
3rdは原点回帰のような作品で、初期衝動を感じながらプレイしていたところはありますね。Cocotame ↗Shiotsuka says “12 hugs (like butterflies)” answered what Hitsujibungaku is, and that with it she felt able to realise some of her ideas.
Shiotsuka: 這張專輯給我感覺到自己能夠實現一些想法了。Sound of Life ↗Shiotsuka says “12 hugs (like butterflies)” did exactly what they wanted and she still loves it; Kasai feels it came out ages ago.
Shiotsuka: 本当にやりたいことをちゃんとやれたなって。気に入ってますね。Real Sound ↗20253
She says finishing “12 hugs (like butterflies)” left her feeling life could end there, and she has never felt pressure to write the next hit.
Shiotsuka: 『12 hugs (like butterflies)』ができあがった時は「もうこれで人生終わってもいい」くらいの気持ちでした。Real Sound ↗Wanting a noisy album next, Shiotsuka put accessible songs like “ランナー” here to move on cleanly; she also thinks it's a good song.
Shiotsuka: 「doll」のようなノイジーな曲を集めた作品を1枚を作りたいんです。Natalie ↗For the new album, she felt she should simply let go of fixed ideas about what her music or the band has to be.
Shiotsuka: “自分の音楽ってこうだよね”とか“うちのバンドってこうじゃなきゃ”とか、そういうものをもう捨てちゃえばいいかなという気持ち。FenderNews ↗