Overall
Comparing Shiotsuka's 2022 and 2026 remarks shows a shift: she has moved from wavering between pop appeal and the band's identity to putting the work first while keeping the band's character through performance and arrangement.
2022
In 2022, Shiotsuka said more than once that the responsibility of helping a show reach people made her overthink tie-in songs and worry that they had to be pop. Finding the point where wide appeal met the band's own identity was hard, she said, and songs outside tie-ins were easier to write. Around the same time, Shiotsuka recalled that the band wrote all kinds of songs before a tie-in was settled, and Fukuda added that there were about four. Kasai, on the other hand, did not feel the band had turned oddly pop at all. Fukuda likewise felt that more had stayed the same than had changed, because even the tie-in songs read closely into each story and apply the band's own words to it. Fukuda also described shaping his drum phrases to suit each work.
2023
In 2023, Fukuda said he keeps in mind that anime tie-ins tend to favour a mainstream sound, and recalled that the four-on-the-floor beat he used on the Jujutsu Kaisen song gave Hitsujibungaku a new sound. Shiotsuka said she enjoyed matching the feel of a series while still bringing in the band itself and its own interests.
2024
In 2024, Shiotsuka said that writing an anime theme within its fixed 89 seconds is extremely difficult, but that the work is interesting and she learns from it.
2025
In 2025, Shiotsuka described her method of reading the original story closely and finding the parts that overlap with her own experiences. She noted that a theme has to intrigue many listeners, pleasing everyone rather than a few, which makes it a different kind of difficulty from album tracks. That same year, Kasai said an anime song starts from the show's content and atmosphere, with the band then working out how to add its own elements, which makes it harder than writing for an album. She added that fitting the show matters more than any particular genre. Also in 2025, Shiotsuka said a tie-in will not pass unless its meaning comes across, which leaves no room for misplaced pride, and that her ability to finish a song as an answer to the task in front of her has grown. She added that putting the visuals ahead of what she herself wants to do has widened the range of what she makes, so that looking back she is, in some ways, freer than before.
2026
In 2026, Shiotsuka herself said she used to think hard about whether a song was unlike the band, but that lately she feels it may be better not to overthink it. The rest, she said, becomes Hitsujibungaku's sound naturally through the band's own playing and its choices in the arrangement.
Every passage on this question, by date11
20223
The anime stories helped her write, but at a major-label scale, working amid many opinions made her lose her way; bandmates feel she hasn't fundamentally changed.
Shiotsuka: メジャーになって規模が大きくなると、いろんな人の意見の中で作業を進めるのが難しくてNatalie ↗Tie-in songs carry responsibility to lift the work, and finding where broad appeal meets their own identity was hard; they wrote about four songs.
Shiotsuka & Fukuda: たくさんの人に聴いてもらうというポイントと、自分たちらしさって何なのか、みたいな。そこが交わる地点を探すのが難しかったですSCHOOL OF LOCK! / TOKYO FM ↗Shiotsuka found the tie-in songs hard, overthinking whether they had to be pop; Fukuda shaped drum parts to suit each film or series.
Shiotsuka: 「ポップにしなくちゃいけないのかな」とか「たくさん聴かれるものにしないといけないのかな」って考えすぎてしまってGINZA ↗20231
They never expected to do anime songs; Fukuda found a new sound with a four-on-the-floor beat, and Shiotsuka enjoyed matching each series while staying themselves, hoping to do more.
Shiotsuka: I enjoyed creating something that matched the feel of the series…Crunchyroll ↗20241
Shiotsuka wants to keep doing anime tie-ins, but fitting songs into 89 seconds is very hard for someone who stretches things out; still, it's fun and educational.
Shiotsuka: 私にとって、アニメはいつも89秒との戦いですCocotame ↗20255
Shiotsuka starts anime songs by reading the source for overlaps with her experience, needing broad appeal; Kasai finds them harder than album songs, which come from within.
Kasai: To me, it is harder to create a song for an anime than for our album.Portland Radio Project (PRP.fm) ↗Shiotsuka says tie-in songs must get their meaning across, leaving no room for silly pride, which has improved her ability to write songs that answer a brief.
Shiotsuka: タイアップってやっぱり意味が伝わんないと通らないんでぴあ ↗Kasai says anime songs needn't be mainstream pop or rock; fitting the show's feeling, visuals and theme matters more than genre.
Kasai: I believe the song should fit the feeling, the visual, the theme of the show…Crunchyroll News ↗Shiotsuka says they'd never written pop songs; anime themes are challenging but she enjoys it, and for “mild days” she drew on a fun dinner with friends.
Shiotsuka: We never really wrote pop songs before.The Japan Times ↗Shiotsuka says for theme songs she prioritises fitting the visuals over her own wishes, which has broadened her range and, in hindsight, made her freer.
Shiotsuka: 自分がやりたいことよりも、映像に合っていることが一番大切だと思うんですよね。Natalie ↗20261
She used to worry about sounding like themselves; now she cares whether the moment the song plays is a good one, letting playing and arranging choices make it theirs.
Shiotsuka: 我現在更在意的是,那個時間能不能成為很好的時間。Unipa ↗